Navigate:
Criticism Corner
Homepage
Writing Index

 

 

Getting Ready To Be Reviewed?

These tips will help you understand where the reviewer is coming from and what they are really doing.

Spider Web

 

 

 

 

 
Whether you want to join a critique group or just have a friend look over your work, these tips will help you prepare and give you a look at what to expect. As covered in previous articles, this is directed towards professional reviewing.
(Items that are personally insulting or "flames" should never be responded to or argued with, that only encourages them. Delete or ignore them immediately.)

 

 

Timeslips Information

 

 

 

 

Quick Tips For Getting Reviews:

1. Be Professional!

If you want a "professional" review, use professional behavior. It may not be what you want to hear, but listen to what’s being said. You never know what wonderful advice you can get from the worst of constructive reviews. Your critics are important whether you realize it or not. They’ll be more honest with you than most people you know.

2. Be Appreciative!

Someone is taking their time to meticulously go over your work, word-for-word. That kind of attention deserves some gratitude. Remember what they find just might have gotten you rejected from a publisher. Or worse, flamed and/or heckled from an angry reader.

3. Be Responsive!

Acknowledge the review. You don’t have to impliment every suggestion, but consider it. Look around online at other professional writing sites, if their information agrees with the advice of other professionals, try it. You don’t have to keep it, don’t even have to officially "change" your work. Just make a virtual copy and try it.

4. Be Realistic!

Don’t think your reviewers will always float around on a cloud of admiration for your work. Professional reviews never do. Expect errors, flaws, and everything else.

5. Be Logical!

No, a reviewer is not flaunting their superiority or arrogance. They are doing what they’re supposed to do, as a friend or an online peer: finding errors. A reviewer is not supposed to inflate your ego or satisfy your insecurities. They are to help, to point out your weaknesses and make suggestions on how to improve or cover them. They help you with what you may overlook. It is a favor to you, whether you want to realize it or not. They will help you look at your work in a new perspective and possibly bring you closer to publication.

6. Be Reasonable!

Please do not be sensitive. Sensitive writers get nowhere until they learn to separate the personal from the professional. Many seem to pout if you say a single "harsh" word about what they’ve written. They don’t take advice, act like they’re doing you a favor just by showing you their work, and become indignant when you make a suggestion.

You may be a misunderstood genius, but until you’ve gotten yourself established in sales and/or reader interest, forget about, "doing your own thing." It isn’t happening in the world of publication. The most you can hope for with that attitude is to land a small contract with a small or independent publisher. Even then, you have to work with their editors. Unless you have a few thousand dollars put back to put your work in print yourself, you have to follow the same rules everyone else does. If you want to, "do your own thing," and nothing more, don‘t attempt a career in the professional world. It’s frustrating and often disappointing. Even if you’re a great published author, you work for the publisher, not the other way around. You’ll always have plenty of competition who would bend over backwards for the publisher.

7. Be Open!

As long as the reviewer is giving you sound advice, try it. You never know. Don’t immediately shut them off simply because they found an er